Does a compressed spring weigh more than an uncompressed spring? The answer is surprisingly yes!
To understand why this is the case, we only need to look at the famous equation, e=mc². Since energy is directly related to mass, adding energy to a system affects the mass the following way: m=e/c². So if we were were to add 1,000 joules of potential energy to a spring, its mass would increase by 1,000 / c² or 1.113 × 10^-14 grams.
The same principle can be applied any time we add energy to a system. For example, heating an object increases its mass, and accelerating an object increases its mass as well. In fact, the reason why it is impossible to go the speed of light is because as an object approaches the speed of light, its mass increases so much that the engines require more and more energy to increase its speed. Accelerating to the speed of light would take an infinite amount of energy.
While these concepts go against common sense, the mathematics behind them are sound.
Sunday, August 16, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Of course the weight is negligible at such a small change. I thought, physics not being a strong suit for me, that the energy in a spring is the same whether compressed or not. Or does that have to do with potential energy?
ReplyDeletethere are different types of potential energy. in this case we would be giving elastic potential energy by compressing it.
DeleteBah, I am an idiot, I remember the answer to this now. The energy is added from the force of compressing the spring.
ReplyDeleteno it's not. this is completely wrong.
Deleteum.... He's actually right.
DeleteNo. This is incorrect. This formula is for mass, not weight. Two different things. The weight of the spring increases (original mass of spring plus force on the spring). The mass never changes. This is an improper use of this formula
DeleteNo, mass actually changes when the spring is compressed, that's what the whole article is about
DeleteYou aren't an idiot, it took humans a long time to learn this.
ReplyDeletehumans never learned this. this is wrong.
DeleteIn equation e=mc^2, the mass is relative.so how it is possible for rest mass. Also the theory of relativity is the theory of moving objects.
ReplyDeleteer..no.. actually that e=mc^2 is ONLY for resting objects, moving objects are E = root ((m_0*c^2))^2+(pc)^2)
Deletewhere m_0 is the resting mass and PC are the euclidian momentum vectors (0 if at rest, which results in E=mc^2).
The full energy of an object is only applicable at speed tho, an object standing still has an "energy level" that, however, does nothing if the outside parameters do not change. If you change the compression of the coil you add to that energy level by giving it eleastic energy (this energy can dissipate by plastic change of the coil to a more dense form)and add some (neglegibly small) amount of mass.
But you also have to equate an object at rest isn't it is just relative to your perspective
DeleteThis is nonsense. The energy is not converted into mass, hence a compressed spring doesn't weigh more at all... unless you're going to contend we can remove the spring and be left with the extra mass that materialized due to the added energy.
ReplyDeleteRight? Your argument makes sense to me... Because if you lifted the mass higher, adding potential energy in the form of height (mgh), would that also cause the spring to increase in mass? In that sense, it's "mass" would be relative to it's proximity to other objects?
DeleteI looked into it and the way I understand it, the claim is right but not in the way the article implies. Not ALL of the energy you put into a spring gets converted into mass. If that was the case, there would be no energy left to actually compress the sting. However, during compression some elementary particles of the Sping's atoms will be elevated into a higher energy state e.g. they get accelerated. As those particles approach the speed of light, they gain a slight mass increase due to the relativistic conservation of momentum. The effect is very tiny an absolutely negligible in any practical sense.
Deletehttp://galileoandeinstein.physics.virginia.edu/lectures/mass_increase.html
Einstein would beg to disagree: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_energy_equivalence
Deletealso, in order to have a mass change of 1 milligram, 0.001g, you would need to add 90 Terajoules of energy, compared to the 63 TJ of the Hiroshima Atomic Bomb.
So even if the physics were right (which it is not), you would need an absurdly large amount of energy to try to see any increase at all.
To be clear, @alcalde, I completely agree. The "debunker" is full of bunk.
Deleteno, alcalde is wrong. Energy and mass have a direct and complete correlation according to most physicists theories. That means energy IS mass and mass IS energy.
DeleteThis is hard to understand I know but thinking there is "conversion" going on here is wrong, there is no converting anything to anything, they are both one and the same, it's useless to disconnect the two and see where they're needed.
And yes, the change in mass is ridiculously small, so what? The saying "does it weigh more" never mentioned a scale. We can assume that these theories are largely correct since all observations till now fit.
About the energy levels, you are thinking very, very small. These calculations also work on other planets, galaxies and so on, potential, kinetic and rest energy change masses of suns, planets, galaxies and so on. Again, the "myth" was only "changes weight", no scale.
@Aaron Wilson, yes the mass changes, however the further you get from the center of the gravitational object, the smaller your gravitational constant g becomes (g=g_0*(r/r+h)^2, where r is the mean radius, h is height above sea level and g_0 is the gravitational constant) so potential energy E=mgh would constantly become smaller the higher you go, this results in an energy flux and thus a mass flux.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThis "debunking" is COMPLETELY INCORRECT. Matter can only ever change into energy in an atomic reaction. And ENERGY CAN NEVER CHANGE INTO MATTER. I suggest you read your physics before you try to "debunk" any further physics related questions.
ReplyDeletehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_energy_equivalence
But your link includes this:
Delete"A spring's mass increases whenever it is put into compression or tension. Its added mass arises from the added potential energy stored within it, which is bound in the stretched chemical (electron) bonds linking the atoms within the spring."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_energy_equivalence#Practical_examples
[citation needed]
DeleteExcept that "citation needed" is an understatement in this case.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. This sounds like someone took E=MC^2 a bit too literally.
Citation found:
Deletehttp://books.google.com/books?id=tpU18JqcSNkC&lpg=PP1&pg=PA87#v=onepage&q&f=false
That blew my mind. But it does seem to have a nice symmetry with the mass increase that accompanies kinetic energy (e.g. as an object's speed approaches that of light, the objects mass approaches infinite).
Have a look at this:
Deletehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Mass%E2%80%93energy_equivalence#Okay.2C_and_let.27s_point_out_early_that_mass_is_never_converted_to_energy.2C_and_vice_versa
Energy can never change into matter? Bullshit. Pair production is a thing - one photon of light energy turning into a particle-antiparticle pair; matter.
DeleteIf the mass/energy of a given system is increased by mechanical tension, that increased mass/energy must come from somewhere. It cannot be created out of thin air. Therefore, the compression mechanism and/or the surrounding air would have to loose mass/energy in order to effect an increase in the spring being compressed.
ReplyDeleteAs a system, the mass/energy of the spring, the compression mechanism, and the surrounding air would remain constant.
The problem with this thought experiment (and let's be clear this is only a thought experiment - no empirical data is available here) is that it is impossible to have the spring compressed and also weigh only the spring or only the compression mechanism. They can only be measured as a system or individually without the compression. Therefore, once they become a system, the weight of that system does not change if one part of the system compresses another.
Not quite. Suppose I do the work to compress a spring and then use a vice to keep it shut. I have lost energy, the spring has gained it. If I measure the sum of the mass of the uncompressed spring and the mass of the vice, it will differ from that of the compressed spring in the vice.
Deleteso, if I have a spring and a rope on a very precise scale and the weigh X. If I tie the rope around the spring to compress it and weight them again, they will weigh X+Y, where Y > 0?
ReplyDeleteFrom my gut understanding no, as the energy added in compression is taken from the atomic bonds within the rope, thus negating the change in energy ergo mass.
DeleteThe confusion here is caused by a misunderstanding of terms. When a system composed of an uncompressed spring is compressed, it has energy/relativistic mass added to it. Relativistic mass and energy are equivalent. However "weight" refers only to gravity's relationship with REST mass, not relativistic mass. Energy cannot become rest mass, therefore the compressed spring will not weigh more.
ReplyDeleteWhen a spring is compressed, it DOES gain relativistic mass. However, since energy and relativistic mass are equivalent, this is the same as saying "When energy is added to a system, it has more energy."
So, if I got this right a TV thats on has more relativistic mass, then when its off?
DeleteI believe that is correct. ANYTHING added to a system, energy or matter, increases its relativistic mass. A tv that is on has more Rel. Mass than one that is off. Heat that tv up in an oven and you have added even more Rel. Mass. Fire it out of a cannon and you've got still more.
ReplyDeleteNow as has been correctly pointed out by other posters, the proportion of the total Rel. Mass represented by the electricity, by the heat, by the motion, by the compression, is extremely miniscule having to be expressed in scientific notation. In order to double the Rel. Mass of our TV, we would have to accelerate it to about 86% the speed of light, which would require a staggering quantity of energy.
Anyway, I am not an expert, just a hobbyist, so I welcome correction. But I think it starts making more sense when you learn to think about Matter and Energy as just different forms of the same kind of "stuff", as counterintuitive as that feels.
Not only is it true but the compressed spring is warmer also.
ReplyDeleteA spring made of iron will weigh more than one made of plastic (slinky, etc.) The same exact principle applies here.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe spring does increase in mass. Suppose the spring has mass m and energy E. Then its rest energy is E = mc^2.
ReplyDeleteNow suppose the spring is compressed. It gains a small amount of potential energy ΔE > 0 and now has mass M.
Then its new energy is E + ΔE = Mc^2.
But E = mc^2, so ΔE = Mc^2 - mc^2 = c^2(M - m).
Since ΔE > 0, then M - m > 0 and so M > m. The spring has increased in mass by M - m = ΔE/c^2.
I read you blog and find very useful information about spring.This is really a thinkable stuff.
ReplyDeletecompression springs
Um i know E=MC2 but........ i hypothesize 2 points; that due to thermodynamics and quantum 'friction' that when a spring is compressed the matter of which it is comprised actually releases the added energy as heat(still within the system) and if said thermal energy escapes the system then the spring will not decompress....
ReplyDeleteAlso the thermodynamic system here in question cannot only be the compressed spring but must also include the 'compressor'.
The link below will help explain this phenomenon. Because empty space is NOT really empty. Believe it or not, empty space is where atoms get most of their mass. knowing that quarks actually make up a proton, there is actually a very small amount of "empty" space between the quarks that make up a proton, and scientist have found that it costs energy to clear out a vacuum INSIDE a proton. and this "vacuum" is the ENERGY that gives an atom 99% of its mass. this is proven by the given the equation E=mC^2. If you rearrange it to solve for m, you get m=E/(C^2), meaning that mass is directly related to energy. the more energy of any object, the greater its mass will be. Empty Space (Meaning its not really empty) is the very foundation that the universe is supported on.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ztc6QPNUqls
Since heat = energy, then this would mean that the hotter something is the more mass it will have. just like a hot cup of tea will have more mass than the same cup of tea at a cooler temperature. if compressing a spring will cause it to raise slightly in temperature, then the mass of the spring will slightly increase as the temperature rises.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J3xLuZNKhlY
ReplyDeleteWell, of course energy can become matter, that's what's been thought to happen moments after the big bang, forming strings, quarks, and eventually hydrogen, and has been proven in the large Hadron collider. Matter is just energy bound up really tightly into a storage form, and what gives matter mass is its energy.
ReplyDeleteDoes this same logic mean that if you lift a spring in the air it will have a greater mass because of GPE?
ReplyDeleteYour explanations for show a comparison between a compression springs and uncompressed is really great.
ReplyDeleteThe spring is one of the most important parts of the suspension. Its very informative and interesting article.all the points are very useful. Simple but very effective writing. Thanks for sharing such a nice post.
ReplyDeleteCompression spring manufacturers
This video explain very nicely why the spring has more mass:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSKzgpt4HBU
E = mc^2 only applies to kinetic energy. Increasing your potential energy does not change your mass. If that was so, then all of us would be crazy heavy, because there is LOADS of gravitational potential energy pulling us towards the Earth. Also, E = mc^2 is mainly used for determining how much energy you would get if you converted the mass of something into energy.
ReplyDeleteDue to the fact that I'm not so good in a science, I find this post informative and useful! Thank you a lot for sharing! Just keep in mind that clicking on http://bigessaywriter.com/blog/winning-emails-how-to-increase-replies, you will know more details about winning emails!
ReplyDeleteWow, it`s quite breathtaking, till I`ve read this article can`t even think that it can be like that. I just start writing about influence of energy on different objects. Thanks from UK Top Writers
ReplyDeleteThat's why we can't break the natural law.
ReplyDeleteIf we can achieve speed of light,time travel would be possible.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteOMG!
ReplyDeleteI didn't know these facts about springs
Compression Springs
ReplyDeleteA very nice and informative post Thanks thanks for the information!
ReplyDeleteApple Laptop Hire
GREAT WORK
ReplyDeletehttps://www.bestassignmentexperts.com/university-assignments-help
Thanks for suggestion. For more visit custom spring manufacturer.
ReplyDeleteI found your this post while searching for information about blog-related research ... It's a good post .. keep posting and updating information. strut-spring-compressors
ReplyDeleteThis blog deserves a legendary award and very wonderfully composed blog.
ReplyDeletebest-spring-compressors
You understand your projects stand out of the crowd. There is something unique about them. It seems to me all of them are brilliant. Best Spring Compressors in 2018 Review
ReplyDeleteGreat website for writing lovers kreygasm meaning
ReplyDeleteGreat Post. Thanks for sharing this informative information.
ReplyDeleteTorsion Springs
Compression Springs
Astronomy has always interested me and it is very difficult to find reliable information and properly researched online. Thank you for providing high quality information you. kissanime
ReplyDeleteMate, you have a endowment. A talent to write highly wonderful articles and on a very ordered basis. I must say that this is a rare talent and you are really making full use of that talent. Good to see that. Gogoanime
ReplyDeleteAppreciate the value! Great post again! Through with this content, you have given stand out introduction. watchcartoononline io
ReplyDeleteThis blog gives us knowledge about physical education and this blog gives some key information about his coaches. So I am glad to found this types of articles. Hatts off mate you wroke a fabulous article and I would like to thank the admin he or she did a polite job here. https://buzznor.com/projectfreetv/
ReplyDeleteIt looks amazing!but the perfect item to wear for this time period is leather jacket,let me tell you a little secret.They are perfect year round. https://99tech.co.uk/caffmos/
ReplyDeleteResearch paper plays a significant role in higher education life. Most advances and spend much time on writing research paper. caffmos
ReplyDeleteReally impressed! Everything is very open and very clear clarification of issues.Naked It contains true facts. Your website is very valuable. Thanks for sharing
ReplyDeleteYour post is very useful,stream2watch I am truly happy to post my note on this blog.
ReplyDeleteYou have shared a very good post keep sharing.Naked
ReplyDeleteHey guys I read your blog is really good and amazing article and I appreciate for your good content article and i hope you work very well in future.Tech - "write for us"
ReplyDeleteHi. I felt so good to read your article. I love to communicate with people and share my knowledge with others. Keep sharing good work.Anime Ultima
ReplyDeleteI am not a good reader. I understand things a little late. But bravo man you have all the power to make things understandable in no time. I appreciate all your efforts. Martie Allen
ReplyDeleteWhat an amazing work shared by you! I loved it and appreciate your writing efforts. Thanks alot for sharing this. Keep posting these type of information pieces. Informationalot
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate your piece of writing. you have explained everything amazingly. Thank you so much for sharing.Shareagain
ReplyDeleteOh, I Am Tired To Found This Type Of Excellent Article. My Friend Told Me And Send Me This Blog Link..well This Blog Give Some Related Information About Fitness. I Really Inspired Your Posting..keep It Up And Update This Type Of Marvelous Information. Amanda Fuller
ReplyDeleteGod's Antique Roadshow is a unique title somehow. As a reader i need to post this blog writers per hour sites just to aware the students about the new ideas. I would like to share this blog with others. ZMovies Gets Closed
ReplyDeleteThis blog was a priceless gift for me, especially. It gives such authentic information which will be very helpful for me and other readers as well. Thanks for writing up this.serenasecurity
ReplyDeleteThanks for writing a superb Blog. On this website, I always see quality depending articles. I also follow you. I want to be the best blogger like you—every time I like to read your writing stuff because I get very useful content there. You do great work.Thanks for writing this simple and interesting.Blog. master anime
ReplyDeleteThis content is very useful for especially students, and they can increase their knowledge and get benefits because they were in search of this content. We should also share such kind of content, so that students can improve their knowledge. Dissertation proposal writing services.
ReplyDeleteIn a my opinion yes Compressed Spring Weigh More Than an Uncompressed Spring because it is have low weigh so it's also more comfort. And to read your article I want to also write on this so please guide me if I did some kind of mistake.
ReplyDeleteBest Master Thesis Help Usa
Great Post, checkout this amazing stuff:- Algebra 2 Tutoring In Los Angeles
ReplyDeleteplay stupid games win stupid prizes
ReplyDeleteThanks For Share Such Great Article
ReplyDeletehttps://www.thefashionhack.com/6-items-to-fix-all-your-fashion-problems/
Thanks for sharing this informative information
ReplyDeletehttps://www.exposework.com/
Impressive！Thanks for the post
ReplyDeleteExplained Guide On Stream2Watch & Its Substitutes
Great Site Thanks https://thefashionmotto.com/
ReplyDeleteI have visited this blog daily and I really enjoyed your blog. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteI also share few good links for user who faces many issues all across the world.
Have a look at FACEBOOK ACCOUNT LOCKED
you have been temporarily blocked from performing this action
Facebook loading problems
Facebook outage map
YouTube is not Working
Recover a Hacked Facebook Account
What a excellent info we will read here. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteHave a look at Bowling Alley Setup Cost in India
Hey!
ReplyDeleteCheck our few popular blogs that will be helpful to you!http://waybinary.simpsite.nl/blog/18593-How_to_open_RAR_files
Google voice conference call
best free email providers
Extra torrent search box
Kisscartoon safe
Amazing blog post that you shared here!
ReplyDeleteI am Amara from Huston. We provide you some emails guide you must learn and resolve it yourself in the email account.
Have a look at
Zoom Internet
Yahoo Outgoing Mail Server
Yahoo SMTP Server
Zoominternet Email
Email Without Phone Number
Verizon Email Address
Thank you for the excellent blog posts. It looks like you put in a lot of effort and time.
ReplyDeleteTop Tech Trends
Thanks for sharing very useful information.
ReplyDeleteCheckout best door solutions provider in usa
Commercial door repair
Thanks for sharing great informational content.
ReplyDeleteFMovies|9anime|showbox apk 2019|vin diesel twin
Are you looking for Refrigerator repair service in Dubai, then you reached at right place where, we have professional workers in our Company. So what are you waiting for just call us today or visit our Website to avail our Service.
ReplyDeleteRefrigerator Repair service in Dubai
nice post..
ReplyDeleteStory Telling USA
Virtual Learning Academy In United States
A hot plate is a self-sufficient portable small appliance used mainly for the preparation of food in location where a kitchen stove on range is not a realistic option and where there is a regular need to move the appliance around from one place to another place. A2zappliancerepairs have a team of skilled and experienced technicians that will give you best service for your Hot Plate Repair in Dubai in a very less time.
ReplyDeleteGodaddy email down
ReplyDeleteGoDaddy email problems with outlook
GoDaddy Email is not Working
GoDaddy emails not sending
Xfinity email
Logged into your Xfinity email account
Godaddy Workspace Webmail Login
Access your Hotmail account
Sign in to your Hotmail Account
Bresnan
Eagle Technical service is a high-profile painting service provider company all over the United Arab Emirates. Our team has been working in apartment painting services in Dubai and Dubai Apartment Painting Services for the last five years. They can provide you the best apartment painting services with the best skilled.
ReplyDeleteif you are looking forPrinter Repair dubai at affordable cost then you came to the right place, we repair all types of printers no matter what brand you have, contact us to know more about our service.
ReplyDeleteIf You Want Your own visa in UAE at a low cost and if you are looking for a company that can provide you with these services, then you have come to the right place. We give a lot of services here like, freelance visa, freelancer visa Dubai, freelance visa Dubai, own visa in UAE, cheapest freelance visa UAE, freelance work permit Dubai.
ReplyDeleteWe have experienced workers for the Home painting services in Dubai, who are certified for their work. So, if you need a Home painters in dubai then contact our Abdullah Technical Services for home painting services.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing a great article. However, if you are looking to know more about Systematic Literature Review, its detailed process, and how it is useful in many research works. Read the article Systematic Literature Review - A Detailed Process
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing great article. These tip are very helpful to me. Also read more Used Engine: How to Find a Junkyard Engine
ReplyDeleteHow to Find the Best Aftermarket Parts
Are you looking to learn how Medical Devices Tested Before Being Launched into the Market, then you have to read this article today. We briefly discuss everything here.
ReplyDeleteWhy You Should Invest In Mobile App Development
ReplyDeleteTop 3 Types of Applications That Can Be Built With Python
ReplyDeleteWhat Features Does Your Mobile App Need To Have?
What is the Cost of Mobile App Development in Ireland?
Why Outsource Your Web Application Development
Top Emerging Trends For Mobile App Development
Which Factors Determine the Total Cost for Mobile App Development?
Types of Web Applications You Must Know
Why It’s Important to Use Network Procurement Services For A Growing Business
How Long Do Germs Remain On Your Clothes?
ReplyDeletehow to recover permanently deleted messages on messenger
ReplyDeletehow to recover permanently deleted messages on messenger
how to recover a deleted Facebook account
Recover deleted Facebook account
We are a Prairieville-based real estate solutions company. If you are a homeowner who is having difficulty selling your property or just needs to sell your home for any reason, don't worry; we are here to help you. Please contact us or visit our website for additional information. https://www.webuyhouses225.com/sell-your-house/
ReplyDeleteHemp Backpack Wholesale
ReplyDeletea compressed spring will weigh more on whatever object is underneath it.Address Millennium Plaza Hotel Tower, Office: 1504, Sheikh Zayed Road, Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
ReplyDeleteContact number - 045864033
For help Free Pickup & Delivery iPhone Repair Dubai
This was a fantastic writing. Thank you for sharing this. I'll undoubtedly return to this website.
ReplyDeletehandyman near me
Your post is really very good, after reading your post, we got a lot of information, thank you from your heart.
ReplyDeleteHandyman Dubai
This article offers clear idea in support of the new people of blogging, that genuinely how to do running a blog.동해출장안마
ReplyDelete삼척출장안마
속초출장안마
원주출장안마
강릉출장안마
춘천출장안마
Just read your post and would like to thank you for maintaining such a cool blog.
ReplyDeletehttps://urbanclap.ae/refrigerator-repair-services/
Your blog has some great post, I'll be visiting again.
ReplyDeleteRead Mine: laptop repair in dubai
"This Blog is Amazing, Thankyou for this Guidence.
ReplyDeleteMBA Entrance Test Preparation in Delhi
Entrance Exam for MBA
CAT Preparation for MBA
CAT Preparation in Delhi"
Career Gurukul is an education and career guidance institute offering career counseling ,skill development programs and BEST CUET COACHING IN DELHI . It helps students achieve academic success and build strong foundations for their professional aspirations.
ReplyDelete